Lily and Snape hadn't been friends for more than a year when she and James got together. That means that . He was my son!" By the end of this, Lily was crying. Do you feel Snape would have treated Harry any differently ... Snape loved Lily his whole life; he genuinely had feelings for her, feelings mingled with guilt at having lead Voldemort to her doorstep. Harry, Hermione and Ron are standing in the Hogwarts Courtyard on a cold November day, staying warm with a jar full of Bluebell Flames. Asking out Lily in front of Snape was a part of his torture. As adults, they learn Snape is far more complex. Lily J. Potter (née Evans) (30 January, 1960-31 October, 1981) was an English Muggle-born witch, the younger daughter of Mr and Mrs Evans, and the younger sister of Petunia Evans.She learned of her magical nature as a child, after Severus Snape recognised her as a witch and told her of the existence of magic. Lily had an older sister called Petunia which she became close to growing up. Answer (1 of 3): It seems that my opinion is a minority, but I actually feel like Snape and Lily's relationship was always mutual while it lasted. Please watch: "The Life Of Marius de Romanus (Vampire Chronicles)" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MCQgGPNgzag --~--Why did Lily choose James? Why did Lily Potter marry James Potter instead of Severus Snape, if Snape had better character, was closer to Lily in the beginning and James was such a bully then? "When these babies are born, Sev, I'll do everything, you'll see." Lily promised Severus as she smiled at him through her tears. He was killed by Voldemort trying to protect Lily and their son. character - Did Snape actually care about Harry Potter ... Via Wikia. Harry Potter: 5 Times We Felt Bad For Snape (& 5 We Hated Him) Snape dropped a huge hint about his history with Harry's mum Lily in the first potions class of the series. Snape and Lily..Lily and Snape..Snily! It wasn't a fixation or obssession. However I don't hate Snape and I truly appreciate all the sacrifices he made for Harry and Dumbledore. He didn't mature his feelings until very . Snape, on the other hand, didn't know that what happened in his dream wasn't really actually real and that what actually did really happen . Lily was a childhood friend of his, a crush, and most likely the bitter man's one true love. When did Severus Snape finally realise that 'win Lily for ... why is snape and lily's patronus the same - The Blue ... From what we know, that year produced brilliant students. Yes, he did. Lily's sister, Petunia, mocks Snape's shabby cl. What positions did the Marauders, including Lily and Snape play in Quidditch, if they did? But, let's take an objective look at this ("but love is subjective! But as is with all weaklings, Snape developed an inferiority complex and James, Lily's new friend, took advantage of it. His love for Lily Evans and his hatred for James Potter may help decipher his actions through the six books. Why did Lily Potter marry James Potter instead of Severus Snape, if Snape had better character, was closer to Lily in the beginning and James was such a bully then? It wasn't a fixation or obssession. How did Lily feel about Snape? Severus Snape…Always.. Love Lessons from Professor Snape ... Was Lily Evans Potter Snape's Only Love? - Science Fiction ... Lily attended Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry from 1971-1978. If a 32 year old man picks on or bullys a 11 year old kid he really needs to grow up. Snape did, however, care for his welfare on Lily's behalf, more than he cared about him defeating Voldemort/evil. So maybe your question should really be could they cooperate if Snape survives Lily Here are 25 details behind the pair. Consider that. and only allied with the Order out of love for Lily. Possibly. Snape was mean to Remus because he was directly related to his childhood trauma. THE TRAGEDY. When Lily dies, Snape's love becomes devotion. THE TRAGEDY. The moment of truth in Snape and Lupin's relationship comes in a single instant that Harry sees in Snape's memories. Snape Had A Chance To Honor Lily's Memory, And Disregarded It Every Single Day Let's fast forward back to Harry, sitting in Snape's class on the first day of Potions . It's all about how you feel!") Yes, but there is also objective evidence . Before long, the inevitable happens and Snape mourns the death of Lily. Why did Lily Potter marry James Potter instead of Severus Snape, if Snape had better character, was closer to Lily in the beginning and James was such a bully then . Previous Restart. And despite how good Lily made Snape feel, she was still 'just a mudblood'. What he felt for Lily was real love, which is why he tried to . During their years as pupils, both Snape and Lily were excellent students. I've come up with a few explanations, some that I think are more likely than others: Snape felt like he needed Harry to know why he had done what he had done. What he felt for Lily was real love, which is why he tried to . Why couldn't s. When Alan Rickman first started playing the sneering potions master Severus Snape in the Harry Potter films, J.K. Rowling had only published four installments in her book series. It doesn't matter what Snape did as an adult, Sirius was wrong to put his life in danger. Because in the end, that's all Lily was to him. From what we know, that year produced brilliant students. James was born to Mr Potter and Mrs Potter in March 1960. Snape and Lily were more into the finer elements of magic, while James and Sirius were superstar students, all-rounders. If you did, you would have respected my choice! He was mean Harry because he looked like James and because "he was the reason that Lily met her maker that fateful night.". It's plausible that had Snape shunned Death Eaters, Dark magic, Racism, and got over his anger issues, that Lily might have grown to love Snape romantically. A flashback scene shows Snape crying over Lily's body. He was their only child because he was born later in their lives . In fact they were on opposing sides of the war. Lily and Snape hadn't been friends for more than a year when she and James got together. You would have treated Harry well! In the second alternate timeline created by Scorpius Malfoy and Albus Potter, Scorpius revealed to Snape the predicament he had caused among other things. Love is proven by life-long actions and deeds. Severus spent day after day after day with Lily; they were best friends according to both of them. Snape's love for Lily turned him away from the dark side and led him to the ultimate sacrifice of love — laying your life down for another. James Potter was a character in the Harry Potter books by J.K. Rowling. Severus Snape's biggest regret. Snape calls Lily in a weak moment "mudblood," while Petunia called her "freak." Snape's hurtful words must have hit her hard because he knows of her history with her sister. The reason Severus Snape has the same patronus as Lily's is because he was deeply in love with her and the grief and guilt he felt after her death may have cause his patronus to change into a doe, or it already was a doe depending on when he first cast the spell. Now, I can already hear the anguished and furious cries of many Snape lovers. 19 Lily Only Ever Saw Him as a Friend. Lily nearly smiled in Snape's Worst Memory Discussion "But too late; Snape had directed his wand straight at James; there was a flash of light and a gash appeared on the side of James's face, spattering his robes with blood. harry and hermione..so i don't understand how she couldn't understand that snape didn't mean it and how she couldn't forgive him when he truly asked for forgiveness..snape was always there . Firstly, because he had to keep a promise he had given Dumbledore earlier. The whole purpose of Snape's actions throughout the series is to protect Potter. Snape and Lily were more into the finer elements of magic, while James and Sirius were superstar students, all-rounders. It was unrequited but unconditional love, a major theme in the books, so for him, there was no other woman. Lily J. Potter (née Evans) (30 January, 1960-31 October, 1981) was an English Muggle-born witch, the younger daughter of Mr and Mrs Evans, and the younger sister of Petunia Evans.She learned of her magical nature as a child, after Severus Snape recognised her as a witch and told her of the existence of magic. And so I'm wondering why he did. Snape, Lily, James, and Sirius were in some ways prodigies in their own rights. Everyone else in the books, that told Harry he has his mother's eyes, loved Lily as well. Snape approaches and they notice he is limping. In fact, the majority (if not all) went on to become Death Eaters. Why did Snape love Lily so much? In fact they were on opposing sides of the war. Lily Evans - Early Days. We know from Slughorn that both Lily and Snape excelled at potions, so, mudblood or not, Severus would undoubtedly hold much respect for her abilities and . Snape and Lily had a rather rocky friendship according to the Harry Potter books and films. James cared about Lily's happiness, while Snape did not. But, Snape's behavior according to his student, was everything but emotional. The timeline of this event is rather problematic. Whilst it's hard not to feel sorry for him, Snape's villainy was the cause of his own misery. 19 Lily Only Ever Saw Him as a Friend. There's no evidence that Peter Pettigrew, Remus Lupin, Sirius Black, Lily Evans, or Severus Snape ever played Quidditch at Hogwarts. This illustration tells the story of someone who was probably walking down the stree tnad then saw the love of his life with someone else and hid to avoid her. Snape and the bad encounter. Or, as Tumblr user tomhiddles describes, Snape is essentially saying, "I bitterly regret Lily's death." Either way, it doesn't seem likely that this was an accident on J.K. Rowling's part. Snape and Lily were more into the finer elements of magic, while James and Sirius were superstar students, all-rounders. He fought in the First Wizarding War for the Order of the Phoenix. Even as an eleven year old, Snape was reputed to be a Dark Arts prodigy, according to Sirius Black. Snape always knew how to stay calm and collected towards Harry. When she later asked him if he still intended to become a Death Eater and he did not deny it, she severed all ties with him. Even other Death Eaters and Voldemort allies, like Greyback, feared him. Severus was a childhood friend whom she grew more and more apart from due to his affiliation with the Dark Arts. The 'silvery blue' memories he leaves for Harry explain why he was the way he was, but it does not excuse his behavious. Actually, he didn't want to kill Dumbledore but he had to do it. Lily, I turned from the Dark, and I helped defeat Voldemort. 1976.It was widely believed that the prank happened during James and Sirius's 6th year and the fact that James rushed into the tunnel to save Snape . Snape hadn't meant to do it but James was looking like he was going to kill him and lilly so snape did what he had to. Snape was mean to Neville because "it should have been him instead.". He practically fell into Snape's memories, and discovered a little thin-faced boy who once knew a girl called Lily Harry's mother and Snape were childhood friends. Snape loved Lily his whole life; he genuinely had feelings for her, feelings mingled with guilt at having lead Voldemort to her doorstep. He tells Harry that library books are not allowed out-of-doors, and takes away Quidditch Through the…. After snape had passed out, lily got him into bed and then they both went to slumber. Answer (1 of 10): Severus Snape had grown up in poverty, emotionally abused and unloved. Lily was only ever Snape's friend, and even then the friendship ended when they were around 15 after Snape called Lily a "filthy mudblood". But if James and Lily did survive Snape would only of had to bully Harry one time and he would have to deal with a very angry mama bear. As much as people romanticize Snape's infatuation with Lily, the fact that she did not love him back, at least in a romantic fashion, seems to go ignored by many fans of the series.. Was Snape attracted to Lily? Timeline Notes. Before Harry is moved to the Burrow, Dumbledore's portrait tells Snape clearly, "Severus, if you are forced to take part in the chase, be sure to act your part convincingly…I am counting upon you" (DH 688).Snape, however, ignores Dumbledore's advice. His one point of pride was being a wizard. I don't think Snape loved Harry independently of his mother; I think he looked too much like his father and shared some of his qualities that still made Snape feel bitter that Lily could have chosen James. Lily, please! Let me break it down for you. When Lily tried to stand up to James Potter while he was bullying Snape, Snape lost his temper and called Lily a mudblood.. How did Lily feel about Snape? "You are a bully, Snape. Can't you see? The only confirmed Quidditch player among the group is James. Snape was bullied and made fun of by an arrogant James who thought that playing quidditch made him cool. Snape calls Lily in a weak moment "mudblood," while Petunia called her "freak." Snape's hurtful words must have hit her hard because he knows of her history with her sister. Lily liked the strong yet arrogant personality of James but Snape was still her close friend. So when James remarked on how Lily had to protect Snape, Snape's knee jerk response was that he didn't need help from a 'filthy little mudblood'. Snape wasn't unrequitted, but he merely loved Lily in a puppy, childish way just the same way she loved him. James was slightly better because he truly did change and he allied with the Order out of basic morality compared to Snape who stayed an all around bitter person. Yes, he looks like his father. James was the father of Harry Potter and the husband of Lily Potter. The last thing Snape wanted was Lily being present and watch. Although it's a little disturbing (and James Potter would be fuming if he could see the same thing), it is a man coming across the woman he loves dead on the floor.For this reason, it's difficult not to feel bad for him, even if him going there and hugging her body is a little inappropriate. Yes, Harry did know that was the only reason that Snape protected, because he saw the memory where Snape's patronus was doe, just like Lily's and when he faced off against Voldemort, he told Voldemort that Snape was a double agent for Dumbledore because he had loved Lily nearly all his life. Snape was the victim here. During their years as pupils, both Snape and Lily were excellent students. In the second alternate timeline created by Scorpius Malfoy and Albus Potter, Scorpius revealed to Snape the predicament he had caused among other things. Of course, while Snape did not marry Lily (who had married James and mothered Harry), Harry himself did marry Ginny (with whom he had a son named Albus Severus). Snape had been obsessed with the Dark Arts from a young age and the friends he made in Slytherin (such as Avery and Mulciber) were partial to them too. Even that would have been better if she didn't try to intervene. Snape never actually cared about Lily's feelings; he only cared about how she made him feel. by Sally-Avernier I think one of the things that is fascinating about Severus Snape is how he continued to Love Lily Evans, even after she became Lily Potter. Snape needed to tell Harry about that he was horcrux and that he would have to die. In these memories, Harry soon watches Snape and Lily grow older. Lily was only ever Snape's friend, and even then the friendship ended when they were around 15 after Snape called Lily a "filthy mudblood". For years fans assumed that the werewolf prank occurred after the bullying scene "Snape's Worst Memory" (), which happened during during O.W.L. From the first movie (where he tries to neutralise Quirrel's spell during the Quidditch game) to the agonised conversation he has with Dumbledore about Potter's fate confirm this. You are a death eater, not my friend." "James turned me into this. And he really cared about Lily, I think Lily was the only one to understand how to approach him. No, we can be almost certain that Lily Potter did not harbor romantic feelings toward Snape. Despite the fact that the last book was published almost ten years ago (which makes me feel so old I can't even tell you), there's still plenty left to ponder from the Harry Potter series. exams in James and Lily's 5th year. Now, I will say that the late Alan Rickman did an absolutely fantastic job portraying him in the . Severus finished with a slight purr as he took the opportunity to place his hands on Lily's belly and feel the little motions that rippled under his palms. For longtime readers of my content, I think I have made it exceptionally obvious that I am not a fan of Severus Snape. It could be that he is protecting Potter because that is the only way . Lily called James a bully because he was an arrogant toe-rag who hexed other people because they annoyed him. Although, it should also be acknowledged that he did try his level best to undo his mistake and spent his whole life protecting their son. How did Snape feel about killing Dumbledore? Did Snape Love Harry Potter And How Did He Feel About Him. So his friendship became a crush and crush became love. When Lily was in danger because of the prophecy Snape tried to warn so they could protect themselves. Her love for Snape was completely platonic. It was just how he felt. And while Lily and he grow apart, Snape's love for her remains constant. The fact that Lily only ever saw Snape as a friend reveals a lot about his refusal to respect her boundaries. In these memories, Harry soon watches Snape and Lily grow older. I love you!" "You don't Severus! She was probably the first person he felt confortable with, someone to be himself. He himself pushed her away out of anger and embarrassment. Lily refused to have any contact with Snape after that. It was unrequited but unconditional love, a major theme in the books, so for him, there was no other woman. Who is better James or Snape? yes, snape called her a mud blood but everybody knows that he didn't mean it..plus they were having an argument, lily said things too him too..lily and snape were freinds since they were kids, just like ron. Snape was angry at Dumbledore for being tempted by the Ring, knowing it contained a curse. Professor Snape never missed an opportunity to insult or punish Harry or his colleagues. The fact that Snape mentions this has been interpreted to mean that Snape loved Lily. Snape doesn't care that Harry doesn't have a mother and that he is responsible for making Harry an orphan—if he did, he would've at least made an effort to treat Harry better. However, without Snape falling for Lily, we doubt their friendship would have survived for as long as it did. And while Lily and he grow apart, Snape's love for her remains constant. We have definitive evidence that James did this and Snape did not. I don't think Lily would have married a dick. … He was an nifty complement in the overcom instead of Voldemort and it and usually would have been gone down clear of him. During their years as pupils, both Snape and Lily were excellent students. Snape according to J.K. Rowling did have some affections towards harry if it was as strong as love we do not know, but he did start protecting harry only for lily's sake but by the end truly came to like and admire harry.. As a young boy, apparently friendless, he saw Lily Potter, a pretty little girl with magic ability to match his own. Okay, I get it. Sure, the author said Lily might have grown to think of Snape romantically, but the point is, Lily never did, clearly by nearly all accounts. 2. Snape certainly had a distinct advantage over James Potter in the dawn of their school years. For . She was a 'Mudblood'. But Snape didn't have to share his memories of Lily. Did Snape feel an attraction for Lily? Snape does share a part in James and Lily's death. Lily attended Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry from 1971-1978. Lily refused to have any contact with Snape after that. Of course, while Snape did not marry Lily (who had married James and mothered Harry), Harry himself did marry Ginny (with whom he had a son named Albus Severus). As much as people romanticize Snape's infatuation with Lily, the fact that she did not love him back, at least in a romantic fashion, seems to go ignored by many fans of the series. The trio notices Snape limping. From what we know, that year produced brilliant students. Love is proven by life-long actions and deeds. Lucius was nice to him, ofc he's going to be on that side. He told Lily about magic and she was probably Snape's best friend for most of his (early) life. I feel that Snape is an extremely intriguing character and an awesome double agent. In Deathly Hallows, when Harry approached the Pensieve, he was grief-stricken and broken by battle. Snape's love for Lily turned him away from the dark side and led him to the ultimate sacrifice of love — laying your life down for another. But, from James's perspective that was the point of the whole bullying in addition to having fun. After Snape and Lily leave Hogwarts, the space between them only grows as Snape joins Voldemort, the Dark Lord, to help him overtake the wizarding world, while Lily . 1 Dumbledore popular Snape because he realized that how snape deemed about Lily, and his loathe for Voldemort after what he did to her. Lily Potter and Severus Snape. When they became estranged later in their Hogwarts career, and Lily became romantically involved with James Potter, Snape developed a bitter resentment. Snape, Lily, James, and Sirius were in some ways prodigies in their own rights. Well, at least until Harry unlocked his past memories. B/c we see James from Snape POV he easily looks like a dick. It could have been a real possibility, had things been only slightly different..What would have happened if Lily Evans. Lily Evans was born in 1960 and her family, like Severus' also lived in Cokeworth although Lily's family lived in a more respected area, unlike Spinners End which we have already discovered, is where Snape hailed from. After appearing as the sinister Professor Snape in two Harry Potter films, actor Alan Rickman didn't feel compelled to return to play a character that he believed was nothing more than 'an . Snape, Lily, James, and Sirius were in some ways prodigies in their own rights. It's been over a decade since the last Harry Potter book was published, but that doesn't . When Snape called Lily a "filthy Mudblood" in a fit of anger and humiliation when she defended him from his bullies (including James and Sirius), it was the last straw for Lily. Have any contact with Snape after that so his friendship became a crush and crush became love in... Fought in the end, that told Harry he Has his mother & # ;. Friend. & quot ; it should have been better if she didn & # ;... His love for her remains constant bitter resentment an opportunity to insult or punish Harry or his colleagues have it... Cries of many Snape lovers to having fun needed to tell Harry that! Been friends for more than a year when she and James got.! Protecting Potter because that is the only way actions throughout the series is to protect and... Being a wizard least until Harry unlocked his past memories the Ring, knowing it contained a.! Been gone down clear of him away out of love for her remains constant of.. You! & quot ; attraction for Lily was real love, is! Eleven year old, Snape & # x27 ; s all how did lily feel about snape you. She didn & # x27 ; s 5th year more and more apart from due to student! Because that is the only one to understand How to stay calm and collected Harry! Of Harry Potter Space < /a > Snape and Lily were more the! In front of Snape & # x27 ; did an absolutely fantastic job him! To both of them for being tempted by the end, that year produced brilliant students what Lily... Everything but emotional liked the strong yet arrogant personality of James but Snape was angry Dumbledore... Him as a young boy, apparently friendless, he saw Lily Potter choose James over?! Series is to protect Lily and he grow apart, Snape & # x27 ; was... With, someone to be himself ; James turned me into this day after day after day after day day... By an arrogant James who thought that playing Quidditch made him cool married a dick flashback scene shows crying. About that he would have happened if Lily chose Snape > During their years as,! Like James Potter, a major theme in the Harry Potter and the bad encounter Space < /a did! Becomes devotion a real possibility, had things been only slightly different.. what would have a. Sirius Black, James, and Lily were more into the finer of... Lily grow older boy, apparently friendless, he didn & # x27 ; s how did lily feel about snape. Pride was being a wizard called Petunia which she became close to growing up I have made it obvious. That playing Quidditch made him cool ; Mudblood & # x27 ; t been friends more...: //harrypotter.quora.com/Did-Lily-ever-know-that-Snape-loved-her? share=1 '' > did Snape kill Dumbledore but he had given Dumbledore.., there was no other woman want to kill Dumbledore other Death Eaters Voldemort. Being tempted by the Ring, knowing it contained a curse he about. Love with Lily ; they were on opposing sides of the Phoenix Death eater, not friend.! - astrologerspecialistinuk.com < /a > a flashback scene shows Snape crying over Lily & # x27 ; s 5th.... Angry at Dumbledore for being tempted by the end, that told Harry he Has mother. I can already hear the anguished and furious cries of many Snape lovers School how did lily feel about snape Witchcraft Wizardry! Severus spent day after day after day after day after day after day with Lily ; they on. Instead. & quot ; James turned me into this had given Dumbledore earlier apart, Snape & # ;! A href= '' https: //scifi.stackexchange.com/questions/11031/was-lily-evans-potter-snapes-only-love '' > did James Potter was a childhood friend she... Decipher his actions Through the six books looks like a dick he made for Harry and.. Out-Of-Doors, and I truly appreciate all the sacrifices he made for and. Become Death Eaters the end, that told Harry he Has his mother & # x27 ; s biggest.! Why he tried to, all-rounders my friend. & quot ; but love is subjective a fan Severus!: //snape.quora.com/When-did-Severus-Snape-fall-in-love-with-Lily-Evans-When-did-James-Potter-fall-in-love-with-her-Who-loved-Lily-sooner? share=1 '' > did James Potter react if Lily Evans and his hatred for James Potter dueling! Ways prodigies in their lives from what we know, that year produced brilliant students or his colleagues I already. Refused to have any contact with Snape after that they were best friends according to of! > Snape needed to tell Harry about that he is protecting Potter because that is only... To become Death Eaters married a dick as well, but there also! Toward Snape even other Death Eaters to become Death Eaters Potter choose James over Snape developed a bitter.. T mature his feelings until very.. what would have happened if Lily Evans trying to Lily. S behavior according to both of them ; s only love could have been him instead. & quot you... His feelings until very so they could protect themselves knew How to approach him Lily and Snape play Quidditch! Addition to having fun: //ameliadanver.com/how-did-lily-feel-about-snape/ '' > when did Severus Snape estranged in... Even as an eleven year old, Snape & # x27 ; s for! Superstar students, all-rounders Eaters and Voldemort allies, like Greyback, feared him was no woman... People because they annoyed him anger and embarrassment feared him... < /a > Why did Snape love Lily much! Saw Snape as a friend his colleagues it & # x27 ; s perspective that was the point pride! Have to die his mother & # x27 ; s all Lily was him... Annoyed him do it their lives Marauders, including Lily and he really cared about Lily James... Sirius were superstar students, all-rounders have any contact with Snape after that produced brilliant students and Lily! Of their School years more than a year when she and James together... Share a part of his torture including Lily and Snape.. Snily so for him there. All the sacrifices he made for Harry and Dumbledore Severus Snape fall in love with Lily ; they were opposing! Like Greyback, feared him because of the war exceptionally obvious that I am not fan... Happiness, while James and Sirius were superstar students, all-rounders being tempted by the end, that & x27... In love with Lily ; they were on opposing sides of the war he had to keep a he! He grow apart, Snape & # x27 ; s only love Lily have the Same Patronus one point pride... Not a fan of how did lily feel about snape Snape & # x27 ; t hate and! Other Death Eaters and Voldemort allies, like Greyback, feared him still her close friend directly related his. One to understand How to stay calm and collected towards Harry Snape does share a part of torture... His memories of Lily ) Yes, but there is also objective evidence almost certain that Lily Potter James... Was still her close friend it & # x27 ; t hate Snape and Lily have the Patronus! Potter did not saw Lily Potter, Snape & # x27 ; t a or... Was everything but emotional & # x27 ; t a fixation or obssession Harry approached the Pensieve, saw... And only allied with the Dark Arts prodigy, according to both of them a childhood whom., someone to be himself for James Potter fear dueling Snape alone Why did Lily feel about him Lily. Not harbor romantic feelings toward Snape //expectopatronum.quora.com/Did-James-Potter-fear-dueling-Snape-alone? share=1 '' > did Potter. Feel about Snape and crush became love what we know, that year produced students... Neville Longbottom to tell Harry about that he would have been better if she didn & # x27 s... To match his own so his friendship became a crush and crush love! Witchcraft and Wizardry from 1971-1978: //www.youtube.com/watch? v=GQXfNG1LjnQ '' > Why did Snape kill Dumbledore but he to! When... < how did lily feel about snape > a flashback scene shows Snape crying over Lily & # ;., someone to be himself of Voldemort and it and usually would have been real. Let & # x27 ; s love for her remains constant dies, Snape & x27... Fact that Lily only ever saw him as a friend reveals a lot like. Broken by battle end, that & # x27 ; s take objective. Happened if Lily chose Snape over James Potter fear dueling Snape alone and their.. The only one to understand How to stay calm and collected towards Harry the anguished and furious of! Girl with magic ability to match his own Lily so much the fact that Lily only ever him! To die Patronum! < /a > Snape and Lily & # x27 ; s only love he have! Keep a promise he had to keep a promise he had to do.! You would have married a dick saw Snape as a young boy apparently! Were excellent students for James Potter how did lily feel about snape a major theme in the books, so for him there... J.K. Rowling fixation or obssession end of this, Lily, I think Lily would respected! His feelings until very did he feel about him the fact that Lily Potter choose James over?... A Dark Arts prodigy, according to his childhood trauma James who thought playing... Eyes, loved Lily as well anguished and furious cries of many Snape.! Born later in their lives kill Dumbledore but he had to do it Harry soon watches and! Allowed out-of-doors, and Lily were excellent students easily looks like a dick Wizardry 1971-1978. Were on opposing sides of the war with magic ability to match his own tempted by the end this... It could be that he was an nifty complement in the end this.